What is the significance of the Gita’s reference to Krishna as Bhagavan because Mahabharata also refers to Shiva as Bhagavan?

by Chaitanya Charan dasJuly 6, 2013

From: Narendra Bhati
I heard in one of the Lectures of Srila Prabhupada where he says that Krishna is Bhagwan thats why in the Bhagvad Gita Krishna is mentioned as “Shri Bhagwan Uvacha”.
Since Bhagvad Gita is a part of Mahabharat, when i read Mahabharat at many places Lord shiva was Mentioned as “Shri Bhagwan Uvach” and yet at many other places i read where Krishna is mentioned as “Shri Krishna/ Vasudev uvach”. Going by this explanation isnt Lord Shiva Bhagvan and isnt Lord Krishna less than Bhagwan.

Answer Podcast

About The Author
Chaitanya Charan das
1 Comments
  • krishna dasa
    October 26, 2014 at 5:04 pm

    If one goes for the technical definition of the word bhagavan ,then it is given in vishnu-purana (6.5.72-75,79) as follows :

    shuddhe maha-vibhuty-akhye

    para-brahmani shabdate

    maitreya bhagavac-chabdah

    sarva-karana-karane

    “O Maitreya, the word bhagavan may be defined as a name of the Supreme Brahman, who is pure, free from all material contamination, full of unlimited powers and opulences, and the original cause of all causes.”

    sambharteti tatha bharta

    bha-karartho dvayanvitah

    neta gamayita srashta

    ga-kararthas tatha mune

    “O sage, in the word bhagavan, the syllable bha stands for the word bharta, which means the maintainer of everything, or the shelter upon whom everything rests, and the syllable ga stands for gamayita, the leader of everyone, or the creator and annihilator of the entire cosmic manifestation.”

    aishvaryasya samagrasya

    viryasya yashasah shriyah

    jnana-vairagyayosh capi

    sanëam bhaga itingana

    “The name bhagavan stands for that Supreme Person who is full in the six opulences (bhaga) of all wealth, strength, fame, beauty, knowledge and renunciation.”*

    vasanti tatra bhutani

    bhutatmany akhilatmani

    sa ca bhuteshv ashesheshu

    va-kararthas tato ‘vyayah

    “In the word bhagavan, the syllable va stands for the verb vas (to reside), because He is the Supreme Personality of Godhead in whom the entire creation rests, and also because He is the Supersoul, who remains in the hearts of all conditioned souls. The syllable va also stands for the word avyaya (unchanging), which indicates that the Supreme Person is eternally the same.”

    jnana-shakti-balaishvarya-

    virya-tejamsy asheshatah

    bhagavac-chabda-vacyani

    vina heyair guëadibhih

    “In this way the name bhagavan means that person who posesses all strength, knowledge, beauty, fame, wealth and renunciation, and all other auspicious qualities, and is also completely free from any fault or defect.”

    Thus in a correct technical sense ,the word bhagavan( as can be seen from the above definition ) applies perfectly to the original form of Lord Krishna .

    But all those avatars of lord krishna including lila avatara ,purusha avatara ,guna avatar ,saktyavesha avatara and other types ,scriptures also refer to them as bhagavan .

    Scriptures at times also refer to Avesha incarnations like Narada ,Vyasa ,Parashurama and four Kumaras also as Bhagavan .And as far as Lord Shiva is concerned ,he is considered to be the Guna Avatara of Krishna .Thus Visnu tattva expansions and anyone who is especially empowered or endowed with some specific potency of Lord Krishna ,scriptures call them as Bhagavan .

    Thus Lord Shiva , have many of the qualities of Lord Krishna in common ,so , scriptures refer to him also as bhagavan ,

    But in a strict and pure technical sense ,Lord Krishna is the reservoir of all the 6 opulence in full ,thus scriptures in order to distinguish Krishna from all other incarnations of Lord including Visnu ,call him ” SVAYAM BHAGAVAN ” .this usage of svayam is explicitly used for Lord Krishna only ,and not to anyone .

    And thus many scriptures like Brahma vaivarta purana and Garga samhita specifically call him Svayam Bhagavan ,thus avoiding confusion .for eg

    sri-sridamovaca

    paripurnatamah sakshac
    chri-krishno bhagavan svayam
    asankhya-brahmanda-patir
    golokeso virajate

    Sri Sridama said: Sri Krishna is the original Supreme Personality of Godhead. He is the master of countless universes. He is the master of Goloka. ( garga samhita )

    and “krsna tu bhagavan svayam ” (bhagavatam )

Leave a Response

Please type the characters of this captcha image in the input box

Please type the characters of this captcha image in the input box

*