Does the M-theory do away with the need for God, as Stephen Hawking claims in The Grand Design?

by Bhavin KatariaMay 27, 2014

Answer Podcast

Quotes by scientists pointing out the limitations of M-theory:

“The connection between this multiverse idea and M-theory is, however, tentative. Advocates of M-theory such as Witten and Hawking would have us believe that it is done and dusted. But its critics have been sharpening their knives for a few years now, arguing that M-theory is not even a proper scientific theory if it is untestable experimentally. At the moment it is just a compelling and beautiful mathematical construct, and in fact only one of a number of candidate TOEs [Theories of Everything].”

– Theoretical physicist Jim Al-Khalili

“It is not testable, not even in any foreseeable future.”

– Physicist Paul Davies

“M-theory is not even defined …we are even told ‘No one seems to know what the M stands for.’ Perhaps it is ‘myth’… I don’t see that M-theory adds one iota to the God debate, either pro or con.”

– Oxford physicist Frank Close

“M-theory is highly speculative and certainly not in the zone of science that we have got any evidence for.”

–  Physicist Jon Butterworth, Large Hadron Collider, Switzerland

“The book is a bit misleading. It gives you this impression of a theory that is going to explain everything; it’s nothing of the sort. It’s not even a theory.”

– Mathematical physicist Roger Penrose

About The Author
Bhavin Kataria

Leave a Response