Prabhupada says Brahma falls whereas Haridas Thakura doesnt but they are the same. Then why the difference? person
From Amal Mahaprabhu Pr
Transcript
This is an AI-generated transcript and may contain some errors.
Prabhupada’s books Question from Amal Mahaprabhu Prabhupada says that Brahma also falls and then he contrasts how Haridas Thakur did not fall down but Haridas Thakur is himself none other than Lord Brahma how do we understand his answer whenever there is a talk about such exalted personalities we have to always understand that there are broader principles being discussed beyond the specifics of the persons talked about so yes Brahma and Haridas Thakur are the same person at the same time they are not in both their respective positions exemplifying the same processes so it is not that all Brahmas are Haridas Thakur only the only a particular Brahma he becomes Haridas Thakur and it is not necessary the same pastime happens in every single age, it is not that every time Lord Krishna and Lord Chaitanya come together every time when Brahmaji feels that he is offended because of the Brahmavidya he desires to become Haridas Thakur so it is not necessary that in all universes all the Brahmas that are there they are Haridas Thakur they eventually become Haridas Thakur so in that sense we have to clearly understand that Brahma is a post different people occupy that post and in this particular kalpa the Brahmavid occupied the post he he he felt the lamentation of having misled of having tried to test Krishna and so he desired to become Haridas Thakur now that is a whole different subject about how they become one but the important principle here is that it is not absolute that every single soul who becomes Brahma, who occupies the post of Brahmaji will eventually become Haridas Thakur so that’s why there can be other Brahmas who are not Haridas Thakur who may follow and even when we are talking about the same person still there is a difference in emphasis the point here is that Haridas Thakur is actually exemplifying in the highest way the process of bhakti and not just bhakti but shuddha bhakti pure, kevala bhakti whereas Brahmaji exemplifies karmamishur bhakti he is certainly a devotee as we see in the second and third cantos of Srimad Bhagavatam when he performs austerity and the Lord blesses him but at the same time we also understand that his bhakti is karmamishur he has the desire to create the universe for the Supreme Lord and that involves some level of karma so because that bhakti is a mishur kind of bhakti so that mishur can lead to complication and that mishur can become the cause of fall down that mishur cannot, its not the mishur becomes the cause of fall down precisely but that mishur makes the person vulnerable to fall down so whatever is the mixing element in that bhakti the karma, if the karma becomes too much above bhakti karma covers bhakti completely and dominates bhakti then the person may go into the path of karma so much and from karma the person may go into the karma and may fall away therefore here its not just a comparison in a only in a literal sense, it is in a literal sense but also indicates that a person so when prabhupada says brahma falls down but darsh thakur doesn’t fall down prabhupada is essentially comparing two processes and he is comparing two prominent exponents of those processes and he is trying to convey to us the superiority of one process over another, superiority of process of kevala bhakti over that of over the process of karma mishra bhakti, thank you