Why is God not humble?

by March 4, 2012

Question: Why does Krishna brag so much in the Bhagavad-gita, proclaiming that he alone is the Supreme, that his glories have no end and that everything attractive is a spark of his splendor? Why is he not humble?

Answer: Before passing judgment on Krishna, we need to understand the application of humility in the context of the philosophical reality and compassionate necessity that underpins the Gita. Let’s look at these three points – reality, necessity and humility – one-by-one:  

Reality: In the Gita Krishna outlines a comprehensive worldview that offers a coherent and cogent understanding of reality. This vision of reality harmonizes seamlessly the many different conceptions of God that have emerged throughout human history: theism and deism, monotheism and polytheism, immanence and transcendence, pantheism and panentheism. This magnificent synthesis culminates in the most endearing conception of a loving and lovable personal divinity, Krishna, as the pinnacle of reality. When Krishna’s Gita statements are seen without this philosophical context, they may seem to be expressions of pride. But when seen within the broad philosophical context, Krishna’s statements turn out to be nothing more than simple affirmations of reality.

Necessity: Our mind may still press on: “Even if Krishna is speaking, why does he have to speak it so brazenly? Can’t he temper it with a bit of humility?” Actually, Krishna does temper his message with humility. Throughout the Gita, he frequently refers to himself in the third person, as in 8.22, 13.23, 15.4, 15.17, 18.61-62. Let’s analyze the third-person self-reference in 18.61-62. Here, Krishna says, “Surrender wholeheartedly to that Supreme Lord who is residing in the hearts of all living beings; by such surrender you will attain the supreme destination and the ultimate peace.” Krishna has already explained in the Gita 15.15 that it is he himself who is the Lord residing in the hearts of all living beings. Yet in 18.61-62 Krishna refers to himself in the third person and thus pre-empts any accusations of arrogance. Krishna’s use of third-person pronoun is similar to that used by a doctor when interacting with a patient: “The patient should surrender to the doctor’s treatment to become healthy.”

The doctor-patient metaphor can give us further insight into the method underlying the Gita’s message. Gita wisdom explains that all of us are patients suffering from the disease of love misdirection. We are all intrinsically and indefatigably love-seeking. Due to not knowing any object of love beyond this world, we seek love in worldly things and beings. However, as all worldly things and beings are limited and temporary, they inevitably disappoint or devastate us. Moreover, our love for the temporary binds us in this temporary world, where we suffer the inevitable miseries of material existence: birth, old age, disease and death.

The only way out of this misery is to redirect our love to the eternal. Gita wisdom aids us in this redirection by revealing in the realm of eternity a supremely attractive object of love: Krishna. As the supreme personal manifestation of the Absolute Truth, Krishna is unlimited and unlimitedly-expanding, everlasting and everlastingly-fresh. That’s why love for him never becomes stale and pale, as does the love of this world; love for Krishna excites and satisfies our heart forever and ever.

Krishna’s act of speaking the Gita is akin to a spiritual rescue operation meant to restore to us the power of wisdom for correcting our love misdirection. It is only to inspire us to focus our love on him that Krishna speaks about his unchallenged supremacy (7.7); it is only to guarantee us that his charm will never fade, as does the charm of everything worldly, that he declares his glories to be inexhaustible (10.40); it is only to reassure us that in loving him we won’t miss anything that we may be enjoying in our present loves that he proclaims that everything derives its potency to attract our love from a spark of his supreme love-attracting potency, his ultimate all-attractiveness (10.41).  

To fulfill this compassionate, curative purpose of the Gita, Krishna at times subordinates humility to necessity. This is what happens when, Krishna, after referring to himself in the third person in 18.61-62, finds Arjuna lost in thought, being unable to decide his exact course of action. Seeing this, Krishna doesn’t let humility come in the way of the necessary clarity. So he proclaims unambiguously in 18.65-66, “Offer all your love to me; abandon all other obligations and just surrender unto me; I will take care of all implications and complications.”

Thus, Krishna’s entire approach is like that of a doctor who, though naturally humble, subordinates humility to the duty of curing the patient. In order to inspire faith in a patient, a reputed doctor may speak his authentic and impressive credentials unhesitatingly unambiguously. An intelligent person will understand that the doctor’s speech is not deficient in humility, but is driven by necessity. When we can thus contextualize the doctor’s speech, why can’t we contextualize Krishna’ speech?

Humility: Krishna still reveals his humility in an extraordinarily endearing way in the Gita – not through its message, but through its setting. Krishna speaks the Gita from the humble station of a chariot-driver, a position that he has accepted out of love for his devotee, Arjuna. The position of a chariot-driver is, more or less, like that of a chauffeur – certainly not a position that a braggart would ever accept voluntarily. But Krishna voluntarily and joyfully accepts this position because his happiness comes not in speaking his own glories, but in reciprocating love with his devotees.

Krishna’s becoming Arjuna’s charioteer is not a one-off fluke, but a graphic demonstration of a perennial principle that animates the highest spiritual realm, Goloka Vrindavana.  Krishna’s message of his own supremacy is meant to point out to us that realm where love reigns supreme. In that world of love, Krishna no longer delights in announcing his godhood; instead, he conceals his godhood by his divine mystical potency and accepts any role, no matter how humble, that best facilitates the intensification and maximization of loving reciprocations with him. Thus, for those devotees like Yashoda who long to love him in a parental mood, Krishna accepts the role of a helpless child and plays it to perfection.

This world of love is our original home and final destination; it is where our heart will discover its ultimate fulfillment and we will actualize our supreme destiny. It is only to invite us to join him in this world of love that Krishna speaks of his majesty and glory. If ever again our mind starts mistaking these statements to be indicative of arrogance, let us remind ourselves that actions speak louder than words, and disarm the mind by meditating on Krishna’s disarming humility as manifested in his actions as a chariot-driver in the Gita and as a child in the spiritual world.

About The Author
  • Bimlaprasad das
    March 4, 2012 at 3:20 pm

    Super excellent explanation!

  • Rishikumardas
    March 5, 2012 at 9:20 am

    The Examples and Analogy of

    1. Docter-Patient

    2. Chariot Driver

    are excellent to answer the question….

    Thankyou very much Chaitanya Charan Pr, to come to this lower level of
    explanations for the understanding of a common man…. this is “Karuna Prakhur”

  • March 7, 2012 at 10:52 am

    Hare Krishna..Impressively and convincingly explained. Thank you.Hari Bol !

  • June 18, 2012 at 2:18 pm

    Hare Krishna!

    Patiently and humbly explained regarding the topic in a clear crystal way to enter the stubborn mind in a sophisticated but simple analogical method to remove whatever doubts, expressed or unexpressed, reg the question. Tackling the question in 360 degree view is your special perception.

    humbly yours

    Hari Hari Bol!

  • Srinivasan
    January 4, 2013 at 9:42 pm

    This is just wonderful! I loved reading this answer. Thank you so much.. Krishna and His devotees are just wonderful.

Leave a Response